Updates, commentary, training and advice on immigration and asylum law
EU Settlement Scheme course now available FREE to members
Ministers still struggle with meaning of “indefinite” detention

Ministers still struggle with meaning of “indefinite” detention

Asked on 21 November about any link between people being kept in indefinite immigration detention and those same people using drugs, Home Office minister Brandon Lewis replied:

We don’t have indefinite detention, so…

It was an assertion Lewis went on to repeat half a dozen times in the space of a few minutes, having said the same thing in the House of Commons the day before. On that occasion, opposition MP Dan Carden made the obvious riposte:

If someone is locked up and not given a timeframe for when they will be released, that is indefinite detention.

Only on Planet Home Office is detention for an indefinite period not considered indefinite detention.

Remarkably, Lewis’s position actually represents progress in the department’s understanding of ordinary English words. He at least conceded that there is no time limit on the period for which someone can be held in detention. This is in contrast to his predecessor as immigration minister, James Brokenshire, who said in a parliamentary debate two years ago:

There is a common misconception that detention under immigration powers is indefinite. I want to make it clear to the Committee that that is not the case. Although there is no fixed statutory time limit on the duration of detention under immigration powers, it is not the case that there is no time limit [emphasis added]. It is limited by statutory measures, the European convention on human rights, the common law, including principles set out in domestic case law, and the legal obligations arising from the Home Office’s published policy, which states:

“Detention must be used sparingly, and for the shortest period necessary.”

Brokenshire was picked up on this by Kier Starmer but stuck to his guns:

Keir Starmer: On the question of “indefinite”, surely the detention is indefinite in the sense that there is no definite limit to it. The detention might not be unending, but it is indefinite in the way that we all understand “indefinite”.

James Brokenshire: Indefinite detention implies detention that cannot be brought to an end..

No, Minister. There really is no time limit, and “indefinite” means (according to Google, Fount Of All Knowledge):

1. lasting for an unknown or unstated length of time.
“they may face indefinite detention”
synonyms: unknown, indeterminate, unspecified, unlimited, unrestricted, undecided, undetermined, undefined, unfixed, unsettled, unresolved, uncertain.

2. not clearly expressed or defined; vague.
“an indefinite number of generations”
synonyms: vague, ill-defined, unclear, loose, general, imprecise, inexact, nebulous, blurred, fuzzy, hazy, confused, obscure, ambiguous, equivocal, doubtful, dubious
“a word with an indefinite meaning”

Or, if you prefer the Chambers dictionary (as I do):

1. Without clearly marked outlines or limits

2. Not clearly distinguished in character

3. Not precise, unclear

4. Undetermined…

That exactly describes immigration detention in the UK. There is no time limit. The limits on detention are unclear and not precise. Immigration detention in the UK is “indefinite”.

I will be sending the minister a copy of the dictionary for Christmas.

Colin Yeo

Immigration and asylum barrister, blogger, writer and consultant at Garden Court Chambers in London and founder and editor of the Free Movement immigration law website.

There are comments on this article.

Only members can view and comment on articles, as well as many other benefits.

Explore membership now
X
Not yet a member?

Get unlimited access to articles, a thriving forum, free e-books, online training materials with downloadable training certificates, and much more.

Worried about preparing an immigration application yourself?

Try our Full Representation Service, provided by Seraphus Solicitors.

Join Now

Benefits Include

  • Clear, transparent fees
  • Fees fixed for each stage of your application or appeal
  • Personal client web access page and messaging system
  • Online payments, document upload & video calls
  • Expert representation
Shares