All Articles: Tribunal

Tribunal retains jurisdiction to vary bail conditions unless bail is finite

UPDATE: overturned by the Court of Appeal in R (On the Application Of Raza) (Pakistan) v The Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] EWCA Civ 807. R (on the application of Raza) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (Bail – con ...

14th March 2016 By

Annual Report of Tribunals highlights urgent areas for improvement

The Annual Report of the tribunal system has been published. The review of the First-tier Tribunal Immigration and Asylum Chamber review starts at page 74. The First-tier report tells of long waits caused by fluctuations in caseload, a long-term chang ...

9th March 2016 By

EU Charter of Fundamental Rights creates freestanding rights in immigration law says tribunal

Abdul (section 55 – Article 24(3) Charter : Nigeria) [2016] UKUT 106 (IAC) is a case involving a Nigerian national aged 41 who had resided in the UK for 25 years and who had two British daughters aged 11 and 13. He had acquired a permanent righ ...

4th March 2016 By

Upper Tribunal criticises Home Office for unfair and unrealistic appeals

In the case of VV (grounds of appeal) [2016] UKUT 53 (IAC) (13 November 2015) the Upper Tribunal yet again criticises Home Office conduct of appeals to the Upper Tribunal against decisions of the First-tier. This case comes on top of Nixon (permissi ...

9th February 2016 By

Judgment in the Calais children case

Full judgment is available here: R (on the application of ZAT and Others) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (Article 8 ECHR – Dublin Regulation – interface – proportionality) IJR [2016] UKUT 61 (IAC). The applicant child ...

29th January 2016 By

Upper Tribunal emphasises again that out of country appeal is adequate remedy

A Tier 4 student prohibited from working was accused of the Home Office of breach of his conditions of leave by taking part time employment. A decision was taken to remove him under the pre-Immigration Act 2014 version of section 10 of the Immigratio ...

21st January 2016 By

Upper Tribunal considers when EEA nationals should be readmitted to UK to attend own deportation appeal hearings

In 2014 the Home Office amended the UK’s rules on EU law deportation cases to allow a deportation to go ahead before an EEA national completes any appeal process against that decision to deport. This has become known as “deport first, appe ...

19th January 2016 By

Upper Tribunal cases on fair hearings in immigration cases

Three recent cases on fair hearings in immigration cases, all from President McCloskey. All make interesting reading. Firstly, the headnote from AM (fair hearing) Sudan [2015] UKUT 656 (IAC): (i) Independent judicial research is inappropriate. It is n ...

13th January 2016 By

Past deception to obtain Indefinite Leave to Remain may lead to status being revoked

The case of Huang & Ors, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (“No Time Limit” Transfer: Fraud) (IJR) [2015] UKUT 662 (IAC) arises from the provision of false or incorrect identity information by asylu ...

12th January 2016 By

Upper Tribunal latest on ETS appeals and common costs orders

I am starting to detect subtle* signs that the Upper Tribunal is unimpressed by attempts to litigate ETS cases from within the UK. These are the cases where a person stands accused (on unknown, undisclosed evidence) of cheating in English language te ...

7th January 2016 By

Presidential Guidance on the Boomerang of Proof

First of all, the official headnote to Muhandiramge (section S-LTR.1.7) [2015] UKUT 675 (IAC) (20 November 2015): Where an application for leave to remain in the United Kingdom is refused under Section S-LTR.1.7 of Appendix FM of the Immigration Rules ...

7th January 2016 By

Costs protection in the Upper Tribunal for legally aided and other litigants

With many thanks to the excellent and eagle-eyed Tim Buley of Landmark Chambers, this post covers the procedural protections against costs orders for legally aided and other litigants in the Upper Tribunal. This is a major issue in judicial review pro ...

17th December 2015 By

Presidential guidance on public interest in removal cases affecting children

President McCloskey certainly isn’t wrong when he says of the immigration rules on human rights introduced in 2012: These provisions of the Rules have generated much jurisprudence during the last two years. In this latest contribution to that ev ...

16th December 2015 By

Quick Reads